Return Policy


Items may be returned within Five business days of purchase for STORE CREDIT ONLY.  

Merchandise must not be worn, washed, or altered in any way.

Merchandise must have all original tags attached and include all accessories received with the order (dustbags, boxes, authenticity cards, etc.).

Merchandise returned without aforementioned accessories will NOT be accepted for return.

All items must be returned in the same condition as received. This includes no odors such as smoke or perfume, Body Odor, etc.

Shipping and handling charges are NOT refundable. Packages received COD will be denied.

If you would like more assistance in making a purchase or have questions such as additional information or pictures of an item please contact us via email at or call (212) 463-7720.


Our standard Return Policy applies to all exchanges. All exchanges must be made within five business days for STORE CREDIT ONLY. STORE CREDIT IS VALID FROM 60 DAYS FROM RETURN ACCEPTANCE.

If your exchange is less in price your original purchase you will be given a STORE CREDIT for the difference. Pilgrim New York will contact you to collect any additional fees if your exchanged item is more expensive than your original purchase.

VINTAGE means that all items are preloved, so please don't expect a brand new item, although all our items are chosen carefully and thoroughly gone over for any noted flaws and are in TOP CONDITION unless, otherwise stated. All item descriptions are honest and exact as possible.

All items are ONE OFF's; items are exclusive, meaning two of the same item is hard to come by, Many of our items are NEW, UNWORN, Special Runway Pieces, Etc. offered at an incredible discount to retail price. We only source from Showrooms, Designer Archives, and Professional Clothing Brokers.  We do not do Consignment or Buy Clothing from Individuals. We guarantee that all items are 100% Authentic and Guaranteed and professionally authenticated by fashion industry professionals.

Join our Mailing List

Sign up to receive our email updates

Search our store